Rudy Giuliani Veterans’ Co-Chairman Resigns Over Muslim Remarks

Border

A co-chairman for Rudy Giuliani’s veterans’ coalition in New Hampshire resigned Saturday after telling a British newspaper that Muslims need to be chased “back to their caves.”

The response was swift after the GOP presidential candidate faced questions Friday night about the comments, made by John Deady during a video interview with the Guardian at a Giuliani house party in Manchester, N.H. Deady was named co-chairman of the New Hampshire Veterans for Rudy over the summer.

“Mr. Deady offered his resignation from his volunteer position in the campaign and I accepted his resignation,” Giuliani New Hampshire Chairman Wayne Semprini said in a  statement.

In the original Guardian interview, Deady said Giuliani is the best candidate to handle “one of the most difficult problems in current history” — “the rise of the Muslims.”

Click here to see the video of Deady’s comments for the Guardian.

He added: “We need to keep the feet to the fire and keep pressing these people until we defeat or chase them back to their caves or, in other words, get rid of them.”

Later in an interview with the Talking Points Memo Web site, Deady confirmed he made the statements and said he was referring to all Muslims.

“I don’t subscribe to the principle that there are good Muslims and bad Muslims,” Deady said in the article. “They’re all Muslims.” 

Click here to read the Talking Points Memo article.

Giuliani’s campaign was quick to contain the damage in the final days before the Jan. 3 Iowa caucuses and Jan. 8 New Hampshire primary.

Similar fallout occurred recently in the Hillary Clinton camp when New Hampshire adviser Bill Shaheen warned in an article that Democratic rival Barack Obama’s admissions of past drug use could provide easy fodder for the GOP if he were the nominee. Shaheen resigned after making the comments.

FOX News’ Carl Cameron and Mosheh Oinounou contributed to this report.

445 Responses to “Rudy Giuliani Veterans’ Co-Chairman Resigns Over Muslim Remarks”

Pages: « 45 44 43 [42] 41 40 39 38 37 36 351 » Show All

Comment by chino66

Finally, a post (#418) that actually makes a lot of sense. Lest anyone think that Islam has a monopoly on killing in the name of religion, it wasn’t that long ago in human history when so-called Christians killed “heretics” because the didn’t follow the teachings of the church (the Spanish Inquisition, Crusades). You’ve had Catholics and Protestants in Ireland killing each other for the past century, in the U.S. there are religious nuts planting bombs and assasinating abortion doctors. Othere religions (not just Muslims) have been persecuting Jews for centuries because of the belief that they killed Christ. So does every religion have its share of nuts and fanatics? Of course they do! But to condemn an entire religion based on the actions on a minority is asinine. I doubt many of the people who have posted here actually know any Muslims personally. I do think there are aspects of Islam which are completely misguided and stupid, but then again, I think that is the case regarding the majority of organized religions. I do believe that moderate Muslims need to do more to speak and act against those segments of their religion who do commit terrorist acts in the name of their religion. Until they do so, the world will paint all Muslims with the same brush. And just like how the Mormons conveniently turned against polygamy when it was in their best interest to do so, Muslims need to look at some of their archaic and backward practices, and realize they had better make some adjustments as well if they expect to fit in with the social norm.

 
Comment by Muhammad

To Cephas,

I can assure you that on my side the candle is lit on both ends. But my problem is that many people on your side just blindly believe what they see on the news or what they read in the newspaper. Yes, there are people who do so many evil things in the name of Islam but tell me, if a driver drives a car recklessly then who is to blame, the car or the driver? About Muslim converts living in fear, well, a minority always lives in fear. And again the problem is that their families and close ones don’t actually study the religion like the converts do. For this reason I ask people just to go through the translation of the Quran and see if what people say about it is true or not.

 
Comment by Jerry

So my comments need moderation? I speak the truth about the Islamic CULT and I get censored. I will again say you need look no further than our own prisons to find the type of people that convert to this phony religion; rapist, murderers, thieves and child molesters. I’m sure I’ll get censored again, but hey some one might get the opportunity to read if before you PCer’s kick me off.

 
Comment by Rick

If the person going by the handle “Educated Muslim” is an example of what they believe to be history then it is an example of how they have re-written history to suit their own view of history. To devout Muslims history does not matter unless it is written by a Muslim. Muslims did not invent anything, they only conquered other peoples and claimed their knowledge as their own invention. Another writer has stated the truth about the development of knowledge and I didn’t see anything the Muslims invented or furthered!

Deception is their most potent weapon in the spreading of their lies to their own populations as well as in the western world. Muslims are allowed by their religion to lie and deceive non-believers without any fear of punishment from their God Allah. It is to their credit if deception of non-believers furthers the cause of Islam. Allah is NOT the same as God in the Bible. YAWEH is not Allah, period!!!!!

If a Muslim converts to any other religion they are to be put to death
If a Christian or Jew publicly expouses their beliefs in a Muslim country they can be put to death
If a woman is raped, under Sharia law she is the guilty party and is punished accordingly
A disobedient woman is to be beaten according to the Koran
Public display of a Bible is against the law in Muslim countries
Prostlyzing any other religion in Muslim countries is against the law and punishable by death
If a non-believer will not convert to Islam they are either taxed to death or physically put to death
A Muslim can cheat, steal, lie, deceive and anything else as long as the party they are assailing are non-Muslims.
Islam claims the Bible has been changed by Jews and Christians and cannot be trusted but the do not consider the evidence proving otherwise such as the Dead Sea Scrolls.

Basically the more educated a devout Muslim is, the MORE dangerous they are, because they have consumed the Kool-Aid in spite of historical, physical and spiritual evidence contrary to Islamis doctrine and teachings.

They do follow a child molesting adulterer who even changed his teachings when it suited his fancy and he did personally behead Jews. Isn’t is coincidental that in the Bible, during the time of the seven year tribulation that believers in Christ are beheaded? I think not! There is a considerable sector of Christian claiming churches are attempting to consolidate all three of the major monothestic religions into one bastardized form of a world religion. Sound familiar?

In closing, Read and Believe the Bible! God opens the eyes of those truly seeking him.

Oh and for you that claim that Jesus never said hes was God you need to understand that YAWEH translates as I AM. The very same claim Jesus made to the Sanhedrin when he said, “Before Moses, I AM” the very day he was crucified!

 
Comment by Cephas

Muhammad, you’re not going to get anywhere with the bigoted bloggers here - I’m sorry to say. But it is not without reason. Not until the followers of Islam learn they must police themselves will you see any improvement in the American (or British) sentiment. Not until over 55 hard line Muslim states are willing to moderate the way in which Islam is practiced in those countries will you see any improvement. Until the Muslim world decides to wake up and embrace the 20th century this will not change. I know from personal experience that Muslims who convert to Christianity spend everyday living in fear of Muslim “hit” squads, mostly from their own families – I’ve seen them convert. That my friend; is a cave man mentality. Sharea (sp?) law is a complete affront to western thought; the fact that it is somewhat acceptable to punish a woman for being raped is ridiculous or that it takes the testimony of two women to equal that of one man in a court of law is just stupid. I could go on and on. But until followers of Islam learn that religion is a matter of personal choice and can’t be forced upon any one will this status change.

The comparative silence of Muslims in the face of the Monsters of Islam speaks volumes.
Instead of trying to change the minds of the more bigoted amongst us, start a little closer to home and encourage your piers to foster the necessary cultural changes to bring Islam into the modern world. Allah will love you for it – seriously.

PS: For those of you who keep harping on about the “Native Americans”. Read up on your anthropology, this continent was apparently one of the last to be settled. Meaning that if you go back far enough, you’ll see that even the Indians were immigrants. Were they treated shamefully, even atrociously; YES absolutely. But that was a different time and culture. Native Americans have every right and privilege I have in this country (more in some cases). Let’s honor their heritage, especially for what it can teach us today, they were and are a great noble people. But get over it already and move on.

 
Comment by Muhammad

To Mr. James McAlister

First, I am not a native english speaker so mistakes should be expected. But to convey my idea was the purpose and I think I did it pretty well.

Second, when I wrote of taking you people out of the caves, you took it literally, whereas I meant it in the sense of awareness and education.

If, according to you people, Islam is a religion of terrorists and ruthless people, then why is that its the fastest growing religion in America and Europe. Does it mean your well educated and literate people are becoming ignorant cave people??

People, instead of following biased opinions, try doing some research for yourselves. You cans start by studying the Quran and seeing for yourselves if what people say about it is true or not.

 
Comment by New Yorker

Anybody who disagrees with #178 is a fake poster!

#178 said “The glaringly fake posters pretending to be Muslims serving in the US Army (first few posters) are obviously plants sent over from the MoveOn and DailyKos sites to falsify that they have some credibility when they in fact don’t.”

 
Comment by New Yorker

That sounds like a description of Bush/Cheney.

#166 said “their view of that freedom is total control of government.”

 
Comment by Ahmad

HI
Somebody was talking about American Heritage? the question is Does America have any appreciable heritage and history? i think the old american history startes with the mass killings of ture natives of this land, i.e indians. And the new American History and heritage starts with the mass murders and killing in Heroshima and Nagasaki. and the lattest one is being written in Iraq and Afghanistan and the rest of the world as the “brave” american soldiers fight against and kill inoocent chlidren and women. Gutts.

When did the amricans and europeans give right to women to vote? Islam gave that right 1500 years back. when did you people give inhericance right to women? Islam gave that 1500 years back.
You peolpe advertise the word Jehad? the word is not even mentioned in Holy Quran or Hadis. it is an Arabic word meaning, ” to struggle”. to struggle against poverty, illitracy, disease and so on. it DOESNOT mean Holy War.
IF there is any example of HOLY WAR in any religion, then it was the Christian Crusades. Which u people are still doing , only now u hve ur media to support it.
i think the common american doesnt even realise it. you people should study islam, stuy truth and facts and then comment .

Ahmad

 
Comment by James McAlister

Mr. Muhammad, let me set you straight on history.

First, Europeans haven’t lived in caves for several thousand years prior to the invention of mohammedism.,

Second, the Dark Ages were the result of your kind and other uncivilized people wreaking havoc wherever they could seek gain while interrupting normal commerce.

Third, the moslems were no repository of knowledge and the idea that they’ve always been highly educated is the brainchild of that dimwit, Lawrence of Arabia. Both the Arabic numbering system and ‘Moorish’ architecture came from India and Indian slaves. Moslems may have stolen a lot of our records during their most successful marauding stage (670 to 1050) but they never used it for any useful purpose. Instead, they preferred to agonize over the rantings of Mohammed who, by the way, purportedly received his epiphony from the arch angel Gabriel in a cave. The earliest breakthroughs in medicine came from the Romans; the Greeks gave us methematics, and astronomy goes back millenia - all pre-moslem and all safely stored and taught in Christian Europe.

By the way, yout beloved Mohammed was illiterate and his heat-exhaustion inspired rantings were copied down by his semi-literate mother and second wife - after he stumbled out of the cave.

Fourth, I can find numerous instances of terrorist-type attackes by moslems in every decade going back to its invention. That’s the nature of your culture and your cult. You refuse to work for it yet you destroy those who do out of simple envy. More heinous is your enslavement of others, such as the annual raids on the Causcasus for forced brides.

Fifth, your grammar is atrocious.

Back to point, we need a strong leader who’s not going to bow to pressures like those of Mr. Muhmmed and remember that he’s to be the American presiden, not some wimpy touchy-feely guy.

 

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Close
E-mail It